Skip to main content

When Is It The Right Time To Replace A Sump Pump?

Written by
Superior Plumbing & Drains, LLC Experts
January 27, 2025
When Is It The Right Time To Replace A Sump Pump?

Sump pumps are an essential part of many homes and businesses, especially those in areas prone to flooding. These pumps prevent water damage and flooding by removing water collected in a sump pit, which is typically located in the basement or crawlspace of a building.

Whether you live in an area prone to heavy rainfall or are located in a low-lying area, a sump pump can save you from costly repairs and water damage.

However, like any mechanical device, sump pumps have a limited lifespan and will eventually need to be replaced. Knowing the right time to replace a sump pump can be challenging, especially if you’re unfamiliar with how it works.

By recognizing the signs early on, you can prevent further damage to your property and ensure that your sump pump is operating efficiently.

There are various types of sump pumps available, and selecting the right one for your needs is essential to ensure that your property is protected in the event of a flood or water damage.

In this article, we’ll discuss the signs that indicate it is time to replace your sump pump and the factors to consider when purchasing a new one.

What Is The Best Time To Replace A Sump Pump?

A sump pump is an essential device that helps keep basements and crawl spaces dry by pumping out excess water that collects in a sump pump basin, but over time it may wear out and malfunction.

So, knowing when is the right time to replace a sump pump is important. Let’s discuss the signs that indicate that your sump pump needs to be replaced:

Age of the Sump Pump

The average lifespan of a sump pump is around ten years, with some lasting as long as even 15 years. If your sump pump is approaching or has exceeded its expected lifespan, it’s time to replace it, even if it is working fine. It’s better to replace it before it fails, which can cause potential water damage to your home.

Frequent Malfunctions

If your sump pump frequently malfunctions, it may be time to replace it. Common malfunctions include failure to turn on, not pumping water, and noises.

If you’ve had to call a plumber to repair your sump pump more than once in the last year, it’s a clear indication that your sump pump is reaching the end of its life.

Excessive Vibration

If your sump pump is vibrating when running, it could indicate that the motor is wearing out or the impeller is clogged.

Excessive vibration can cause a damaged sump pump and lead to failure. If you notice your sump pump vibrating excessively, it’s time to consider replacing it.

Strange Noises

A sump pump that makes unusual noises when running is another sign that it’s time to replace it. A sump pump that emits loud, grinding, or rattling noises could indicate a failing motor or a clogged impeller.

If your sump pump is making strange noises, have it inspected by a professional to determine if it should be replaced.

Increased Energy Bills

A sump pump that uses more energy than usual to operate could be another sign that it’s time to replace it. As a sump pump ages, it may become less efficient, causing it to use more energy to pump the same amount of water.

If you’ve noticed a significant increase in energy bills and your sump pump is approaching its lifespan, consider replacing it with a more energy-efficient model.

Water Damage

If your sump pump is not functioning correctly, it can lead to water damage in your home. If you notice any water damage around your sump pump in the basement, it could be a sign that your sump pump needs to be replaced.

Don’t wait until it’s too late to replace your sump pump to prevent further water damage to your home.

Visible Rust or Corrosion

Rust and corrosion can cause the motor to fail, rendering the sump pump useless. If you notice any signs of rust or corrosion, it’s best to replace your sump pump as soon as you can to avoid any potential water damage to your home.

What Are The Factors To Consider When Purchasing A Sump Pump?

If your sump pump shows any of the aforementioned signs, it may be time to replace it with a more efficient model. There are several factors to consider to ensure you select the right one for your needs.

Here are some key factors to keep in mind when purchasing a new sump pump:

Type Of Pumps

Pedestal pumps and submersible pumps are the two primary types of sump pumps. Submersible pumps have motors inside the sump pit, whereas pedestal pumps are positioned above it. A sump pump submersible is typically more expensive but is quieter and less visible.

Power Source

Sump pumps can be powered by electricity or a backup battery. If you live in an area with frequent power outages, a sump pump battery backup is essential to ensure the pump continues working even when the electricity is out.

Capacity

The capacity of a sump pump refers to how much water it can handle per minute. This is an important factor, as you would want to ensure that your pump can handle the amount of water in the sump pit.

Float Switch

A sump pump float switch turns the pump on and off as needed. Some sump pumps have adjustable float switches set to different levels, while others have fixed switches. Adjustable switches offer more flexibility, but fixed switches are typically more reliable.

Brand and Warranty

Choosing a reputable brand and looking for a pump that comes with a warranty will ensure that you’re getting a high-quality product that will last for years to come.

Tips To Avoid Replacing A Sump Pump In An Emergency

While sump pumps are essential to protect your property from water damage, it’s always better to avoid replacing sump pumps in an emergency.

Here are some tips to help prevent a sump pump emergency:

  • Regular Maintenance: Cleaning the sump pit and checking the discharge line for clogs or blockages can help keep your pump functioning properly.
  • Battery Backup: Investing in a battery backup system for your sump pump can help prevent emergencies during power outages. Make sure to check the battery backup regularly to ensure that it’s in good working order.
  • Check Valves: A sump pump valve check is essential to prevent water from flowing back into the sump pit. Regularly check the valve to ensure it is functioning properly and replace it if necessary.
  • Proper Installation: Ensure that the sump pump installation is at the correct level in the sump pit and that the discharge line is properly connected.
  • Know The Signs: Knowing the signs of a failing sump pump can help prevent an emergency. Watch for unusual noises, frequent cycling, and other signs of malfunction. If you notice any of these signs, address the issue promptly to avoid a potential emergency.

Key Takeaways

In conclusion, a sump pump is crucial to protecting your property from water damage. In addition to knowing the right time to replace your sump pump, it’s also crucial to consider the factors involved in purchasing a new one. Besides, regular maintenance and proper installation can help prevent the need for emergency replacements and keep your sump pump working effectively.

At Superior Plumbing and Drains, LLC, we understand the importance of having a reliable sump pump system in your home or business. Our team of experts can help you select the right sump pump for your needs, and our professional installation and maintenance services can ensure that your system works for years to come.

Contact us today to learn more about our sump pump services and how we can help protect your property from water damage.

Customer Reviews

Why you need our superior services


  • Bobby B.
    Thank you to both Scott and Brendon. They did a great job taking care of my issue. In addition, they went the extra mile to ensure things were work as they should and planned a follow up the next day to ensure everything is still good. I’ve been using Superior Plumbing for over 8 years. I would highly recommend Tim and his team because they care about great customer satisfaction as well as the community!!
  • Patricia H.

    When I needed a plumber due to a water issue at my home, Superior was the only company who not only responded with the quickest appointment time but called to let me know that due to a cancellation they were able to come even sooner. I especially appreciated the text message I received prior to the technician arriving, showing me his picture as well as his name. Walker, the technician, was professional, highly knowledgeable, and …Read All Reviews

  • kathy k.
    Thank you Superior for such prompt, reasonable, professional service when we were without water. You are worthy of your name! We will be sharing our experience at Superior with friends that may need plumbing or well services in the future.
  • Kevin L.
    We discovered a slow water line leak in our home that was starting to damage our flooring so we needed help right away. I did not have prior experience with Superior Plumbing & Drains in the past, but reached out to them for help. They were able to schedule an appointment with me quickly. The responding Technician, Walker, was very professional and courteous and took the time to explain the problem and repair to …Read All Reviews
  • Kristin G.

    I had an emergency plumbing situation in my short-term rental & Superior Plumbing went above and beyond to help me out in a time pinch. The staff was KIND, HONEST, & thorough, without price gouging! I would HIGHLY recommend to anyone!

  • Matt L.
    They were able to respond quickly when our water heater quit working. One of their plumbers came to the house, inspected heater, recommended replacement and explained clearly why he was recommending replacement. He then gave options of different prices and types of heaters. Once we made our choice they completed the work the next day. I would recommend this company without a question.
    Flexible Financing

    Budget-friendly financing for your plumbing needs


    At Superior Plumbing and Drains, LLC, we’re committed to making your plumbing projects affordable and stress-free. That’s why we offer multiple flexible financing options (subject to credit approval) to help you tackle any plumbing need with ease. Explore our financing solutions today and discover convenient ways to manage your next plumbing project!